Specificatii drepturi de autor RSS

[miealex]

Salut,

Vreau sa-mi cer scuze de la bun inceput fiindca n-am gasit un topic adecvat. Este o chestie care ma preseaza f. tare in momentul asta. Voi posta aici ... daca este cazul rog unul dintre admini sa mute postul unde trebuie. Multumesc anticipat!

Recent un tip care are poze pe flickr.com mi-a dat email spunand:

please stop blogging my all rights reserved photos from flickr.
this site is clearly just an api-feed fed ad revenue generating site, there is no fair-use argument to be made.

best,
adam lawrence

... raspunsul meu:

Adam I'm very sorry if you feel like this but we're taking all the pictures that are PUBLIC and tagged "graffiti" on flickr I have no way of separating them

As you can see they have the original poster of the photo so we aren't taking any credit over them. We're just presenting them on site, that's all.

Thanks for understanding,
Alex

PS: One suggestion. Try not to tag them "graffiti"

... tipul revine ...

Alex

You misunderstand the term "public" on flickr. By blogging photos marked "All Rights Reserved" you are in fact violating my copyright, and the copyrights of many other photographers. What you need to do is switch your robot to only link photos with a Creative Commons license that allows commercial use and remove all photos that aren't being legally used. I am glad that you aren't stripping attribution etc, but you still need to remove the All Rights Reserved pics and re-program your website. Just out of curiosity, how much money does your site make in any given day?

Best, Adam

Siteul in cauza este romaniangraffiti dot ro. Este vorba despre rss al imaginilor PUBLICE pe search term "graffiti". Pe pagina de RSS a Flickr nu exista referire la copyright ... cu toate astea eu dau credit Flickr si autorilor pozelor respective in fiecare post / poza luata cu RSS. Mai mult chiar: eu pe site nu am specificat ca romaniangraffiti dot ro ar fi copyright Alex Mielus tocmai in ideea ca preiau prin rss munca altora.

Are sau nu dreptate? Incalc copyrightul?

[Krumel]

RSS Specifications
Intai citeste si apoi fa.
Preluarea de continut prin rss are si ea o limita. Nu poti lua ce vrei tu si cum vrei tu indiferent de modalitate, daca nu dai drepturi de autor celui indreptatit.

Materialele sint mult mai multe. O sa revin daca nu gasesti nimic.

[miealex]

http://www.rss-specifications.com/rss-etiquette.htm

If someone complains about having a blog post copied, what should you do?

The appropriate course of action would be to remove the offending post and replace it with text that explains why the post was removed. Even if you feel the post was simply fair use, and not a copyright violation, net courtesy dictates that you respect the wishes of the original poster and remove the content.

Problema nu e de drepturi de autor (linkul siteului si posterul original ale pozei apar in fiecare post), sau de lege ... ci de "net courtesy". Daca vreau sa le pastrez in site nu m-ar opri nimeni, decat bunul-simt.

DECI ar trebui sa sterg acele posturi cu imagini ale lui Adam Lawrence.

Merci de link Krumel.

[myamar]

Folosirea neautorizata ale creatiilor altor persoane tine de "fair use".

Cel care ti-a scris ti-a reprosat ca acest tip de folosire nu poate fi invocat pentru ca e clar (pt el) ca "this site is clearly just an api-feed fed ad revenue generating site", deci e doar o masina de facut bani.

Impresia asta e data de adurile google camuflate alaturi de imaginile respective. E ca si cum ai invoca fair use catre Rolling Stones pt folosirea la inceputul unei reclame a unei melodii.

[BogdanM]

Miealex,
Tipul are dreptate. Trebuie sa dai jos pozele lui.
In schimbi poti lua din Flickr pozele care sunt notate ca fiind in domeniul public sau sub o licenta CreativeCommons. Exista si in alte baze de date astfel de poze.
Faptul ca Flickr ofera poze prin RSS, nu inseamna ca iti da si dreptul sa le pui pe situl tau..

Legea in cauza e legea romana - vezi Cap Vi Legea Drepturilor de Autor pentru exceptii, si nu de linkul dat de myamar.

[Krumel]

Multumim Bogdan.

[miealex]

Notat, sters, intrebat la nenei la Flickr, invatam folosit API pentru luat DOAR CreativeCommons images ...